|
I have a stern
dislike for mistruths, and there appears to be some about me, my company and one
of it's products, I feel the need to set the record straight.
In 1997, I had a customer purchase a 1985 Honda GL1200 LTD. He had done a great
deal of research on the Internet in regards to the bike and it's potential
problem areas. Of course, the stator was #1 on the list. We emailed each other
several times in regards to the bike, his wishes, and we set an appointment.
Among other things, he brought me a stator harness that was marketed thru Saber
Cycle that had been designed by Campbells Electronics.
As I understood, a company called Ray's Small Engines had bought the rights to
from Campbells to build the harness. It appears that
Campbells is again building and marketing the harness
as of Feb 2005.
The harness I was presented with had Xeroxed instructions that bordered on
unreadable. Here are the problems I found with the unit:
1. The harness itself was very poorly built.
2. The gauge of wire on several legs was too small.
3. There were redundant connections.
4. The coils were being powered constantly, even with the key off.
5. Power for the coil wires was not fuse protected.
6. The harness used all low quality solder less connectors that were not crimped
using the proper tool.
I did not understand some of the design of the harness. I called Ray's Small
Engines and got very vague, short answers. I asked if there was a way for me to
contact Mr. Campbell and I was told no. At this point, I set out to redesign the
unit to:
1. Use the proper wire gauge for the load (usually one gauge higher than
needed).
2. Have soldered connections at all high load connection points.
3. Remove power from the coils when the ignition was off.
4. Apply fused protection where the other lacked it.
Our design worked very well in testing. It accomplished all the things that us
and our customer had hoped for. And at the time, was a lot less money than the
Saber Cycle product.
Did we design the harness? No. We redesigned it. Never have the words come out
of my mouth or anyone at my shop (that I am aware of) that we designed the unit.
So what about the statements Campbells makes in
regards to our product? Since I do not have permission to reproduce exactly from
their page, I will get as close as I can without
infringement:
You
will pay too much.
Our harness uses American made wire, is silicone sleeved, includes an
non-Asian integrated relay for coil power switching
and is hand soldered on all high current connections for maximum current flow
with fuse protection.
You
will get a copy of their first harness design that
uses fuse holders that are not sealed so water can get in and ruin them.
While our fuse holders do not have covers, they are an OEM product that allow us
to seamlessly integrate the fuses into the wire without additional connection
points. Also, our main power wire to the regulator is a very high strand count
10 gauge wire (high strand flows current better). There is not a waterproof fuse
holder with this level of quality wire in 10 gauge that I have found. And unless
you have the side cover off when you are washing or riding the bike, water has a
difficult time making over the side cover, up and under the seat and into the
small gap left by the fuse in the fuse holder. We have recently started to
include dielectric grease to fill the small gap left between the fuse and fuse
holder so this is a moot point.
You
will get a harness that has an ignition relay that will fail from vibration.
Our relay is built by Hella and is an OEM quality product found in automobiles
everywhere. And it is not an ignition relay specifically; it is a Universal
design that is the most popular format on the planet. Easily replaced anywhere
in the world if necessary. This unit is rated at more than 5 times the load and
switches off power to the coils so that they are not constantly powered. If a
relay was subject to damage from vibration, why would virtually every vehicle on
the planet use relays?
They released a few of this early
version to let 'us' steal and copy it, while they
went on and quietly improved the design.
According to their website, they
invented the harness about 1992. We redesigned the harness in 1997. You do the
math.
You
will get poorly crimped connectors to fail. Crimp connectors are the problem.
They are why your Gold Wing is having problems now.
We use the "Super Crimper" brand hand crimpers from Hitachi that are an OEM
Honda dealer tool. There is no better hand crimper available anywhere for the
application. All of the high current flow connections are crimped and soldered.
The problem was indeed the connectors, but not necessarily the crimps. The
connections were flowing more current than they could handle. This is why 1200's
would melt and discolor the 3 pin connector from the stator. Too much current =
heat. Every wire on your motorcycle terminates into a crimp of some sort; ring
terminal, battery connector, mini pin that is inserted into a multi-pin
connector. If crimps were truly such an issue, Honda and every other OEM would
have stopped using them years ago.
You
will get an inferior and mass produced item.
The only other person that has built this harness other than myself is someone I
personally trained and has been building them for the last 6 years. We build 15
to 20 at a time by hand in our Knoxville shop.
No
technical support available.
Unless you call when I am out of the office, I can
walk anyone thru the install and troubleshoot installation issues. I can't help
you with the fuel injection though.
So what's my background? GWRRA member since 1983, #28340. Check out this photo:
http://www.electricalconnection.com/family.JPG
That’s me in the red shirt next to my first Gold Wing in 1984 heading to the
GWRRA CA State Rally in Fresno. I was 18 years old and a senior in High School.
My first bike was a 1983 Honda Silver Wing. I started wrenching on Wings in
1982. I worked for my father at a motorcycle touring shop in Laguna Hills, CA
called "Custom Touring Design." This place was responsible for a large portion
of the product offerings from Markland Industries during this era. The shop was
able to integrate the Honda CB into the radio for the first Yamaha Venture as
Yamaha did not have a CB available. The install was so clean and worked so well,
Yamaha sent a bike to the shop to have a radio installed and based their product
off our design. Did I design the conversion? No, but was taught by the person
that did. We had some of the most talented Gold Wing techs anywhere in the US.
When the dealer could not repair a Wing, we ended up with the bike. The shop
developed powered center stands, shifters, and numerous other items that were
not currently available at that time. We were also a testing facility for all
the major tire manufacturers.
Except for a few years that I served with the US Army as an Air Traffic
Controller, my whole life has revolved around motorcycles and most specifically
Honda's Gold Wing. I have Service Manuals and ETM's for every Wing since 1982.
While I may not have everything about the Gold Wing's
electrical system committed to memory,
we know how to decipher the factory
ETM to determine fix for any problem that is not from
one of the bike's computers.
Lewis Q. Preston,
Proprietor
Feb. 27, 2005
|